Reviewing Flaws in "Art: A Brief History"

The textbook Art: A Brief History covers art history throughout the world quite extensively and makes a flawed and poorly executed attempt at accurately and impartially representing all cultures, times, and regions. While accounting for the disparities and disproportionality in the amount of coverage for different regions and cultures, the authors simultaneously become self aware of their faults while also being dismissive at times of the problems in the textbook. Its flaws are not rare or small, most obviously being glaring issues in the text regarding the lenses and perspectives from which different art is viewed, the biases in those views, and the way that art is organized in the book and explained. 

From the onset, it is clear that there is a heavier emphasis on a Western-centric point of view, most clearly shown by the layout of the Table of Contents. Starting first with the oldest art and ending with the most recent art, while moving around the world in each overall time period, one can see how the authors have distinguished art from Western and non-Western areas. A whopping 14 of the 20 chapters are centered wholly or mostly around Western art, greatly outnumbering the 6 remaining chapters meant to include the rest of the world. Even further, the breakdown here generalizes large swaths of people; there is a single chapter in the book titled “African Art”. It is unacceptable, as well as impossible, to accurately represent the entirety of the history of art from the innumerable cultures and societies that have lived on the African continent. Other failures by the authors in addressing non-Western art are the virtually complete absence of art from Pacific Island cultures and the generalization in the chapters on “Early Asian Art” and “Later Asian Art”.

The authors of the book also make what appears to be an unconscious bias against non-Western art and the way they describe and explain the art. Western art is viewed more favorably and is approached more respectfully, contrasting the information provided for non-Western art. There is a distinct lack of information and context available on the cultures that much of the non-Western art is from, compared to art from the Renaissance, for example. This disparity further deepens the divide in the book and makes it more difficult to view and appreciate art from different cultures equally.


Art Comparisons

(Figure 1)
Figure 1

            In chapter eight, “Arts of the Islamic World” in Art: a Brief History the text for the Dome of the Rock is first presented with historical background on the significance of the location to the Jewish, Christian and Muslim religion. The textbook explains how Muslims identify as the place from which Muhammad ascended to the presence of God on the “Night Journey” described in the Qur’an. The same rock is also associated with the creation of Adam; the place where the patriarch Abraham prepared to sacrifice his son, Isaac, at the command of God; and the site of the temple of Solomon, making it important to Jews and Christians, as well as Muslims (Stokstad & Cothren 205). The textbook then gives a brief explanation on how other Roman, Byzantine and Chritain structures have been incorporated into aspects of the Dome of the Rock but they don’t give specific examples. This is key information to understanding how other cultures have influenced the Omayans which show’s there’s a role of primitivism in the textbook. 


Figure 2


            Looking back on how the textbook presented the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in chapter eleven, “Gothic Arts of Europe'' you can see there’s a difference in the amount of historical context that’s provided about the artworks. Adding onto that, the two images used in the textbook of the Dome of the Rock depict a distant side view of the exterior and of the interior. Going back to the Cathedral of Notre-Dame, the textbook uses images of the building that are closer up so you’re able to see the designs on the exterior in more detail. As seen in Figure 1 and Figure 2 the images presented in the textbook of the Dome of the Rock are so dark and far away that the viewers can hardly see the mosaics and inscriptions details (Stokstad & Cothren, 206).  The mosaics and the inscription are so significant to the Dome of the Rock and we know things because they completely take up the whole interior.Yet, the textbook presents the mosaics through text and describes the use of plants, vines, jewels, gold, white and blue patterns instead of using images. Although, the textbook fails to mention that the mosaics are inspired from Byzantine mosaics and borrowed traditions like depicting vegetation and blue/gold color schemes (Lecture 10/8). Along with that, the textbook also leaves out detail about the inscriptions on the interior of the building. The inscriptions tie in all three religions by claiming Jesus and Moses are prophets but only Muhammad is divine. By doing this the Omayans are gaining power by contributing other religions but at the same time praising the Quran (Lecture 10/8). A key component the textbook fails to mention is the overall purpose of why the Dome of the Rock was constructed, even though it was inspired by religion it’s not a place of worship. We know that the Omyans who were taking over Jerusalum at the time wanted to gain power and authority so their first step was to take prime real estate which was the Dome of the Rock. Claiming the Dome of the Rock was strictly to gain political power and authority by borrowing from older traditions and religions (Lecture 10/8). Compared to the way the Gothic arts are presented in the textbook to Islamic art there is overall less detail and specifics on the historical background and connections to other cultures in the text. We can also infer that the way the buildings are depicted through images there is some favoritism to the western chapters by using better quality and overall more images/ diagrams. This may be due to the fact that the authors of the textbook don’t value non-western art as much as western and that’s why there’s more content in those sections. The problem with this is that certain context on cultural and religious influence can be crucial to understanding the significance of the artwork. A modification I would make to the textbook would first to use images that depict the most significant aspects of the art that also relates to the text. It doesn’t make sense to talk about the mosaics and inscription in the structure but not provide a quality image of them. 


Figure 3

As seen in Figure 3 the image really captures the detail in the design of the inscriptions and mosaics (Lecture 10/8). This is the type of image that should have been presented in the textbook. Additionally, the non-western chapters specifically the Islamic could have been executed better by providing the same amount of historical background and influence just as the textbook did for the western chapters. Overall, there could have been a more balanced fashion with how the chapters are presented through text and images in the book.

            

Figure 6

            The section of the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in the chapter of Gothic Art talks about the style that was rising and becoming known in the European art and in architecture. The Gothic style of architecture that was borrowed by Islamic architecture. Influenced by other architecture the Notre-Dame was built in the early Gothic building in the thirteenth century. The textbooks chapter focuses primarily on the details and elements that went into building with the intention of portraying Adam and Eve.  The cathedral was a place for worship and to show art in their details and design but they wanted it to be more than that. They wanted this cathedral to present Paris as a whole because Paris has recently been liberated from the Nazis (Stokstad & Cothren, 270). Not forgetting the main feature of architecture in the cathedral which were the windows and the colors that gave life to the interior of the cathedral. This technique of adding stained glass to the cathedrals made them beautiful and colorful and they weren’t just random designs they were stories or had a background to them. The textbook mentions the process of the creation of the cathedral and pieces that were put into the constriction of the cathedral. Mentioning how one of the side windows was donated by King Louis IX as a form of requisition of his ruling. The sole purpose of these windows was to get as much light as possible into the structures.  Not only this but another fundamental element about the cathedrals is the pointed arch which is again is borrowed from Islamic culture.


Figure 7

    This was made for the purpose to support and not just for looks. It made it easier for weight to be supported since the overall weight of the structure was going down (Lecture 10/16). Even though most of Gothic art seem to be for religious purposes not everything was like that for Gothic art. The most common and well known were the churches giving the idea that all Gothic art was religious. The layout of the inside of the cathedral was usually the same as others. The images that are used in the textbook that show the Notre-Dame are shown in figure 6 and 7. The images that the book includes show major detailing and proportion of the structure. When seeing how the textbook talks about Dome of the Rock it is quite clear that the book doesn’t give much detail like how it does for the Gothic section. The amount of detail in information is less for the Dome of the Rock. When it comes to the actual similarities about both structures the textbook mentions coloring about the structures. You can say that the textbook talks about that when comparing both looking at it through the book. One other thing that we can see that the textbook talks about both is that they are places of religion but we already know the main purpose of each structure because of lecture. The text book doesn't really mention much detail about the Dome of the Rock which is something I say the book lacks. The book does a very good job in talking about the Gothic art by the amount of information it contains and what seems to be preference over the other. The imagery that was selected for the Gothic art was more detailed and more in quantity. The non-western section of the textbook lacks historical background that is not a problem for the western section. This could be a result of preference or lack of knowledge by the author. A change that I would make to the textbook would be adding the same amount of background information to sections of the book and not make it like there is a preference for one. Additionally, I would make sure that every detail about what I am talking about is included because it seems to lack some background that we’ve learned in class that is important that is not included. Overall, the context of the textbook is very rich but lacks a sense of equality in the sections.

Two more important changes that should have been made in the textbook are the following: the focus of the chapters not concerning European or American art should have been covered more thoroughly and been broken down into several other chapters. “African Art”, for example, should not be a single chapter; there should be several chapters on art from various Asian cultures and regions rather than an umbrella chapter. Providing equal importance to all art is imperative, and making a change to be more inclusive of underrepresented and even ignored cultures and arts in the textbook would be a marked improvement.

Secondly, the perspective the authors take on the role of primitivism in the Art History world leaves much to be desired. Rather than only provide a brief explanation on why viewing art as primitive is wrong and not provide any accountability, there should have been a more in depth explanation on what actions the authors have taken to correct this. Moreover, the inclusion of this small section comes off as dismissive when taking into account the flaws and actions the authors took in reducing and compressing the role of African and Asian art in the textbook.


Art Detective

(Figure 4) Arch and vault at Stanford University
Figure 4

Figure 4 is a photo taken at Stanford University. It shows a simple arch and vault, as developed by the Etruscans and Romans. The arch is used to create entryways and separate areas of walkways and hallways, while also creating barrel vaults intermittently. The arches and vaults at Stanford are very similar to those of churches and cathedrals that utilized the same basic principles. - Anthony Michel


Figure 5

    Figure 5 was taken on the UC campus and it was a placement for an art class. I decided to take and use this picture because it reminded me a lot of the Asian Art culture and the Mayan because of the vases and ceramic in it. The body figures that are in the picture remind me of the mayan because of the body face figures in the piece. The center brown vase in the center also contains mayan patterns and designs. It was also made of the same material that the mayan used to make their pieces. The elephant in the back gives this feeling of asian culture because it was a significant animal that brought a lot of symbolization. Overall the pieces that are in the picture come together to form a piece that feels that could belong to multiple art cultures. - Jorge Mendieta


Figure 8

    After learning about Greek and Roman architecture I started noticing how some styles and techniques are still used in structures today, even in places like my own home. In Figure 8 we can see the use of columns which is a post that usually consists of a shaft and a capital. This specific column resembles a Tuscan order column which was a style used by the Romans but was originally influenced by the Greeks. It’s order is similar to a Roman Doric column but Tuscan columns have an unfluted shaft and a simplified base, capital, and entablature. It’s made out of white marble which was a common material to use in ancient Rome. - Jolie Mason


Conclusion

    In conclusion, the textbook and its authors present a very flawed view of global art history, though admittedly make a better attempt than most other textbooks. The bias the authors have in under representing non-Western art and not making any effort to correct views of primitivism heavily weigh down any positive effect the text may have. Its strengths lie in the coverage of Western arts. This much, though, is unsurprising for a textbook on art history written from a Western perspective. However, despite being passable, it is not right to recommend to any reader this textbook on its own. Anyone seeking to gain a firm, accurate, and unbiased understanding of global art history must consult other resources in addition to the textbook to account for the deficiencies in the non-Western art chapters.


Group 11

Jolie Mason, Jorge Mendieta, Anthony Michel

Word Count: 2550






Comments

  1. great and very detailed analysis on the textbook

    ReplyDelete
  2. Loved that you went straight into your opinion and voiced the flaws of the textbook, I agree! -Mireya Arana

    ReplyDelete
  3. loved the intro paragraph, really drew in your audience!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like the organization of your blog post! It was a good read

    ReplyDelete
  5. I enjoyed reading the art detectives, especially the structure found in the home. Its cool to see how architecture from back then is still used in modern houses. -Nikki phan

    ReplyDelete
  6. I loved what you guys brought within your art detectives. Its great to see your guy's thoughts on the textbook bias.

    ReplyDelete
  7. the blog post is well organized and good labeling with images included .-Janessa Gomez

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great and lengthy read! Great job!

    - Justin Ya

    ReplyDelete
  9. I really liked the selection of figures this group selected. The only thing I caught that could be fixed was that everything was labeled except the introduction and include/exclude appears to not be displayed. - Jade Woodworth

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think the introduction was done well. Specifically when you focused on how there was an Western-centric emphasis and then you gave examples to back up your opinion. -Julinna Fletes

    ReplyDelete
  11. The flow of the blog is very straightforward and I enjoy that a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  12. overall a good blog, very well detailed in the comparisons section and fun to read!

    ReplyDelete
  13. very detailed analysis and comparisons, great job - Gabe De Pina

    ReplyDelete
  14. this blog post gets to the point and provides great information about the book. I also enjoyed reading the Art detectives.
    - Ivan Vargas

    ReplyDelete
  15. i like the layout of the blog, the pictures help with understanding your analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It was cool to see Greco-Roman influences in your own home, how fascinating.

    ReplyDelete
  17. You got straight to the point and explained how it had a bias towards Western art. Love it!- Valerie Guerrero

    ReplyDelete
  18. I really enjoyed your almost complete use of architecture in you blog for comparison and personal detective work. ~Brennan Garcia

    ReplyDelete
  19. The work is very blunt and there is no beating around the bush. I really like this blog because it is easy to follow.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I loved how the images were numbered which made it easy to follow along. The analysis was well detailed. Nice Job! - Lucero Ascencio

    ReplyDelete
  21. We really enjoyed this blog as the introduction is not only very direct, but it's a personal perspective rather than simply discussing the qualities. Like everything, there is always room for improvement, this book is no different. We really enjoyed the art detectives section, specifically figure 8, as we also believe that now we are able to spot various artistic elements we encounter in our every day lives. We, however, don't think the book is so terrible that one cannot read it independetly. We think that although this book has an really bias to the Western world, it is up to the reader to pick and chose what is appropriate in order to learn and be able to recognize this bias. All in all, we reallly enjoyed hearing this perspective as it offers a different approach.
    - Group #10 (Andrew-Lara Kane, Chelsy Librado, Araceli Mancilla).

    ReplyDelete
  22. I really enjoyed your descriptions and organization of the images all in the middle it was pleasing to view, good job! - Lisset Ochoa

    ReplyDelete
  23. Well done! I like how you used mainly architecture as example and images for this blog. All the images used for art detective section was really interesting because of the locations.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I enjoyed the art detective portion because of the different perspectives you all had.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Good post. I agree with you that the case against "primitive" art could be expanded on but I think the overall trend the authors are showing gives hope for more inclusiveness as art history progresses.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Even though the grammar of the text could be improved, I was still fascinated by the art detective images.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I liked the images chosen and used for this post.

    ReplyDelete
  28. What I most liked about the blog post were the pictures that were included because it went along with everything said after or before.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Your information was presented in a well thought out way, nice job.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I really enjoyed the introduction and how you guys mentioned that the bias was not small and not noticeable but a big fault in the textbook. - Cristina Molina Cortes

    ReplyDelete
  31. I enjoyed reading the art detective section, great job!

    ReplyDelete
  32. I thought your art comparisons were really good and I liked how you got straight to the point in critiquing the book. -Stefania Ortiz

    ReplyDelete
  33. Very good and detailed analysis made throughout the post! Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  34. I really enjoyed the blog post and how you were able to connect it to aspects in your own homes!

    ReplyDelete
  35. I like that you gave suggestions on what could be changed about the textbook to improve it

    ReplyDelete
  36. The comparisons were very detailed. I really liked the objects chosen for the art detectives.

    ReplyDelete
  37. We enjoyed how well written and persuasive your blog was, and also enjoyed reading the changes you would make to the textbook. Well done! (Amber, Clarissa, and Katerina)

    ReplyDelete
  38. Iris Gutierrez: The overall blogpost has a clear thesis and I find the main body paragraphs to well support it.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I really like how the blog is very easy to follow and while you scroll you are seeing the whole assignment ! well done!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Pretty cool images used for the art detective and your statement about how the textbook didn't provide a full coverage image to the non-western art is something i didn't know about :) cool commentary !

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment